Keywords: Chinese medicine, Chinese herbal medicine, gastro-enterology,
gastro-esophageal reflux disease (GERD)
Gastro-esophageal reflux disease, commonly
referred to as GERD, or acid reflux, is a condition in which the
liquid content of the stomach
regurgitates (backs up, or refluxes) into the esophagus. This results
in the subjective sensation of heartburn and may cause inflammation
of the esophagus. GERD is a chronic condition. Once it begins, it is
usually life-long. If there is injury to the lining of the esophagus
(esophagitis), this also is a chronic condition. Moreover, after the
esophagus has healed with Western medical treatment and treatment is
stopped, the injury will return in most patients within a few months.
As many as ten percent of Americans have episodes of heartburn (pyrosis)
every day, and 44% have symptoms at least once a month. In all, GERD
affects an estimated 25-35% of the US population. Psychological well-being
questionnaires have found that patients with GERD can have a worse
quality of life than some patients with menopausal symptoms, peptic
ulcer disease, angina, or even congestive heart failure. GERD is one
of the more popular disorders for research published in Chinese medical
journals in the People's Republic of China. Therefore, there
is a large body of literature on this subject in Chinese suggesting
that Chinese medicine provides safe and effective treatments for this
condition. Below are abstracts of recently published Chinese research
on GERD.
Clinical Trial #1
On page 53 of issue #5, 2005 of Guang Ming Zhong Yi (Guangming
Chinese Medicine),
Li Fu-wang published an article titled, "Observations on the Therapeutic
Effects of Treating 86 Cases of Gastro-esophageal Reflux Disorder with Chai
Hu Shu Gan San Jia Wei (Bupleurum Course the Liver Powder with Added Flavors)."
Cohort Description
Altogether, there were 164 outpatients enrolled in this two-wing comparison
study. All met the diagnostic criteria for GERD established at the August
1999 Chinese Gastroenterology Symposium. These 164 were randomly divided
into two groups – a treatment group of 86 and a comparison group of
78. In the treatment group, there were 30 males and 56 females with an average
age of 41 years. In the comparison group, there were 28 males and 50 females
with an average age of 39 years. The average course of disease in both groups
was three months. In the treatment group, 72 cases also had a diagnosis of
chronic cholecystitis, 25 had a diagnosis of gallstones, 43 had a diagnosis
of chronic persistent hepatitis, and six cases had a diagnosis of endohepatic
vascular tumor. In the comparison group, the incidence of these accompanying
diagnoses were respectively 65, 22, 36, and five.
Treatment Method
All members of the comparison group received 20 milligrams per os b.i.d. of
luo sai ke jiao nong (an unidentified, presumably Western pharmaceutical)
and one tablet of Ulcerlmin ten minutes before meals. The treatment group
took the same Western medicines and, in addition, the following version of
Chai Hu Shu Gan San Jia Wei:
Chai Hu (Radix Bupleuri), 12g
Zhi Ke (Fructus Aurantii), 12g
Bai Shao (Radix Paeoniae Albae), 12g
Chen Pi (Pericarpium Citri Reticulatae), 15g
Chuan Xiong (Rhizoma Chuanxiong), 10g
Xiang Fu (Rhizoma Cyperi), 15g
mix-fried Gan Cao (Radix Glycyrrhizae), 10g
One packet of these medicinals was decocted in water two times per
day to obtain 600 milliliters of medicinal fluid which was administered
in two divided doses morning and evening.
If there was simultaneous qi stagnation, Xiao Yao San (Rambling Powder)
was added.
If there was spleen-stomach vacuity weakness, 12 grams of Bai Zhu
(Rhizoma Atractylodis Macrocephalae) and 15 grams of Fu Ling (Poria)
were added.
If cold dampness was exuberant, 12 grams each of Gao Liang Jiang (Rhizoma
Alpiniae Officinari) and Gui Zhi (Ramulus Cinnamomi) were added.
If there was liver-gallbladder damp heat, 20 grams of Long Dan Cao
(Radix Gentianae) and Liu Yi San (Six [to] One Powder) were added.
If hiccup and vomiting were severe, 15 grams of Xuan Fu Hua (Flos
Inulae) and 20 grams of Dai Zhe Shi (Haemititum) were added.
If there was constipation with dry, bound stools, 10 grams of Da Huang
(Radix Et Rhizoma Rhei) were added.
If the disease was mild, the above medicinals were administered until
the symptoms disappeared and then continued for one more week. If the
symptoms were severe, the medicinals were continued for four weeks.
Study Outcomes
Outcomes were based on a point system for the ranking of endoscopic findings.
Cure was defined as zero points. A marked effect was defined as a decrease
of two points. Some effect meant that there was a decrease of one point,
while no effect meant there was no change or that endoscopic findings worsened
by one point or more. Table 1 shows the outcomes based on these criteria.
Table 1: Clinical Trial #1 Outcomes
Group |
Cured |
Marked Effect |
Some Effect |
No Effect |
Total Effect |
Treatment |
38 |
20 |
16 |
8 |
86% |
Comparison |
23 |
15 |
12 |
28 |
64% |
These outcomes showed that the combined
protocol of Chinese and Western medicine was significantly more effective
than the Western
medical
treatment alone (P + 0.05).
Discussion
It is Dr. Li's opinion that this condition's disease mechanism
is a mutual binding of phlegm and qi and that it is mostly associated with
psycho-emotional dysregulation. The liver governs coursing and discharge. On
the one hand, this means the coursing and discharge of bile; on the other,
it means the regulation and smoothing of the affects and mind. If the qi mechanism
is regulated, the spleen is able to fortify and transport, and the stomach
is able to accept and absorb. If the liver qi becomes constrained and depressed,
there is loss of coursing and discharge, and the qi mechanism becomes obstructed
and stagnant. The liver channel spreads to the rib-sides. Therefore, liver
depression manifests as chest and rib-side distention, oppression, and discomfort.
Spleen loss of fortification and movement leads to the duct and abdomen developing
glomus, congestion, and discomfort. Stomach loss of harmony and downbearing
leads to nausea, hiccup, and vomiting. Within the above formula, Chai Hu courses
the liver and rectifies the qi, regulates and eases the flow of the qi mechanism.
Zhi Ke rectifies the qi and moves the qi. When combined with Chai Hu, the clear
is upborne and the turbid is downborne. Bai Shao nourishes yin and restrains
yang, emolliates the liver, and relaxes tension or cramping. When combined
with Chai Hu, one scatters and the other collects. Together, they rectify the
liver qi. Bai Shao plus Gan Cao is able to relax cramping and stop pain. Chen
Pi moves the qi and harmonizes the stomach. Chuan Xiong quickens the blood
and transforms stasis. When combined with Bai Shao, the qi and blood are both
rectified at the same time. Xiang Fu moves the qi within the chest and strengthens
the force of the movement of qi. When all these medicinals are used together,
their effect is to course the liver and rectify the qi, fortify the spleen
and harmonize the stomach, regulate and harmonize yin and yang, free the flow
and normalize upbearing and downbearing.
Clinical Trial #2
On pages 544-545 of issue #6, 2005 of the Shi Yong
Zhong Yi Nei Ke Za Zhi (Journal
of Practical Chinese Medicine Internal Medicine), Liao Mao-jie published
an article titled, "The Treatment of 80 Cases of Reflux Gastritis with
Self-composed Jia Wei Chai Hu Shu Gan San (Added Flavors Bupleurum Course
the Liver Powder)."
Cohort Description
Altogether, there were 160 in-patients enrolled in this two-wing comparison
study who were equally and randomly divided into two groups of 80 each – a
treatment group and a comparison group. In the treatment group, there were
52 males and 28 females. Forty-four of these were aged 25-40 years, and 36
were 40-55-years-old. These patients had suffered from this condition for
one to three years. In the comparison group, there were 53 males and 27 females.
Forty-three of these were 26-40, and 37 were 40-54-years-old. These patients
had likewise suffered from this disorder for one to three years. Therefore,
both groups were judged to be statistically comparable. In terms of diagnostic
criteria, there was upper abdominal distention and fullness, pain, burping/belching,
upper back and rib-side distention and pain, a bitter taste in the mouth,
and torpid intake. In addition, fiber optic endoscopy showed marked hyperemia
and edema of the stomach mucosa as well as varying degrees of bile entering
the stomach. Patients with other digestive system diseases and duodenal ulcers
were excluded from this study.
Treatment Method
All members of the treatment group were administered the following Chinese
medicinals:
Yin Chen Hao (Herba Artemisiae Scopariae), 15g
Lian Qiao (Fructus Forsythiae), 15g
Yu Jin (Tuber Curcumae), 15g
Chai Hu (Radix Bupleuri), 15g
Bai Shao (Radix Paeoniae Albae), 15g
Xiang Fu (Rhizoma Cyperi), 15g
Zhi Ke (Fructus Aurantii), 15g
Chen Pi (Pericarpium Citri Reticulatae), 15g
Chuan Xiong (Rhizoma Chuanxiong), 10g
Gan Cao (Radix Glycyrrhizae), 10g
One packet of these medicinals was decocted in water and administered
per day in two divided doses, with 30 days equaling one course of treatment.
All members of the comparison group were administered 3.75 g t.i.d. of Wei
Kang Ding Pian (Stomach Health Calming Tablets) plus 45 mg t.i.d. of Ma Ding
Lin Pian (an unidentifiable Western drug). Likewise, thirty days equaled one
course of treatment in this group.
Study Outcomes
Marked effect was defined as the disappearance of subjective symptoms and the
basic disappearance or marked improvement in endoscopic findings of inflammation
of the gastric mucosa. Improvement meant that the major portion of gastric
mucosal inflammation was under control and the bile reflux had basically
disappeared. No effect meant that neither of the preceding criteria were
met. Table 2 shows the outcomes of these two groups based on the foregoing
criteria.
Table 2: Clinical Trial #2 Outcomes
Group |
Marked Effect |
Improvement |
No Effect |
Total Effect |
Treatment |
61 |
13 |
6 |
92.5% |
Comparison |
35 |
15 |
30 |
62.5% |
These outcomes show a marked statistical difference
in outcomes between these two groups (P + 0.01).
Discussion
According to Dr. Liao, reflux gastritis is relatively difficult to treat, and
it has basically two disease mechanisms. On the one hand, there is stomach
qi congestion and stagnation with spleen loss of movement and transformation
due to unregulated diet or external evils assailing the stomach. If depression
transforms heat, this may then burn and damage stomach yin, resulting in
inflammation of the gastric mucosa. On the other hand, due to worry, too
much thinking, anxiety, and anger, the affects and mind lose their regulation,
and the liver qi may become depressed and bound. Then liver wood may check
earth. The spleen then loses its movement and transformation, and water and
warmth collect internally. This may brew and transform heat, and this warmth
and heat may ascend to steam the liver and gallbladder, resulting in loss
of the liver's control over coursing and discharge. Hence, the bile
is not able to be descended and drained to the small intestine but, instead,
erroneously enters the stomach. This then causes even more inflammation of
the gastric mucosa. Therefore, in sum, Dr. Liao believes that this condition's
disease mechanism is mainly a liver-spleen-stomach disharmony. Jia Wei Chai
Hu Shu Gan San is thus designed to course the liver and resolve depression,
disperse inflammation and disinhibit the gallbladder, regulate and harmonize
the liver and spleen, fortify the spleen and harmonize the stomach. Since
the medicinals match the pattern, this treatment is markedly effective.
Clinical Trial #3
Campylobacter pylori has recently been isolated from gastric mucosal biopsy
specimens. Campylobacter pylori produces abundant quantities of urease, and
this property has been used to develop a rapid diagnostic test. The organism
is found predominantly beneath the gastric mucosal layer that lines the surface
epithelium of the stomach. Infection with C. pylori causes an acute histologic
gastritis which may become chronic. The bacterium is the etiologic agent
in type-B gastritis. Prevalence of the organism in asymptomatic persons appears
to be age-related. Campylobacter pylori is found commonly in patients with
peptic ulcer disease, always in association with chronic gastritis. Eradication
of the organism is associated with healing of the gastritis and a lower relapse
rate in duodenal ulcer disease. On page 553 of issue #6, 2005 of the Shi
Yong Zhong Yi Nei Ke Za Zhi (Journal of Practical
Chinese Medicine Internal Medicine), Zhou Qiong published an article titled, "The Treatment of
60 Cases of Gastritis Associated with Campylobacter Pylori with Qing You
Tang (Clear the Secluded Decoction)."
Cohort Description
There were 37 males and 23 females enrolled in this study. These patients were
17-68 years of age, with an average age of 45. They had suffered from gastritis
for 0.5-28 years, with an average disease duration of 6.3 years. All the
patients had had electron gastroscopy, and tests for Campylobacter pylori
were positive in all cases. In terms of Chinese medical pattern discrimination,
all presented a pattern of spleen-stomach damp heat, the signs and symptoms
of which included stomach duct pain, torpid intake, reduced appetite, burping/belching,
clamoring stomach, acid eructation, abdominal distention, lack of strength,
headache, irregular bowel movements, an abnormal taste in the mouth, a fat,
pale red tongue with teeth-marks on its edges and yellow, slimy fur, and
a soggy, moderate (i.e., slightly slow) pulse.
Treatment Method
Qing You Tang consisted of the following:
Cang Zhu (Rhizoma Atractylodis), 15g
Hou Po (Cortex Magnoliae), 10g
Chen Pi (Pericarpium Citri Reticulatae), 10g
Gan Cao (Radix Glycyrrhizae), 6g
Huang Lian (Rhizoma Coptidis), 6g
Zhu Ru (Caulis Bambusae In Taeniis), 10g
Pu Gong Ying (Herba Taraxaci), 15g
Zhi Ke (Fructus Aurantii), 15g
Pei Lan (Herba Eupatorii), 10g
Fu Ling (Poria), 10g
Ma Bo (Lasiosphaera/Calvatia), 10g
One packet of these medicinals was decocted in water and administered
per day, with one week equaling one course of treatment.
Study Outcomes
Outcomes criteria were based on Shi Yong Zhong Xi
Yi Jie He Zhen Duan Zhi Liao Xue (A Study of
Practical Integrated Chinese-Western Medicine Diagnosis & Treatment).
Cure was defined as disappearance of clinical symptoms one month after treatment,
disappearance of signs of active inflammation of the stomach, and extensive
improvement in the signs of chronic inflammation. A marked effect was defined
as basic disappearance of clinical symptoms, basic disappearance of signs
of acute inflammation of the gastric mucosa, and improvement in signs of
chronic inflammation after one month. Some effect was defined as a marked
decrease in clinical symptoms, shrinkage of the areas of pathological changes
of the mucosa by one half or more, and a decrease in the signs of inflammation
after one month. No effect meant that none of the above criteria were met
after one month. Based on these criteria, 35 cases were judged cured, 19
got a marked effect, four got some effect, and two got no effect, for a total
effectiveness rate of 96.7%.
Discussion
According to Dr. Zhou, gastritis associated with Campylobacter pylori is categorized
in Chinese medicine as stomach duct pain, glomus and fullness, clamoring
stomach, and swallowing acid and is commonly due to either a liver-stomach
disharmony, spleen-stomach damp heat, spleen-stomach vacuity cold, or qi
stagnation and blood stasis. In Dr. Zhou's experience, most patients
present a pattern of spleen-stomach damp heat. Therefore, Dr. Zhou's
treatment principles are to clear heat and disinhibit dampness, arouse the
spleen and clear the lungs. Within the above formula, Cang Zhu, bitter, warm,
and of a dry nature, eliminates dampness and fortifies the spleen. Hou Po
moves the qi and transforms dampness, disperses distention and eliminates
fullness. When combined with Chen Pi and Gan Cao, these medicinals comprise
Ping Wei San (Level the Stomach Powder), which dries dampness and moves the
spleen, moves the qi and harmonizes the stomach. When Huang Lian is added,
these medicinals then dry dampness and clear heat. Pu Gong Ying clears liver-stomach
depressive heat, clears heat and disinhibits dampness. Zhu Ru transforms
phlegm and stops vomiting, while Ma Bo clears heat and depurates the lungs.
This is based on the fact that the stomach's flow is normal when it
is harmonious and downbears and the lungs govern the qi's depuration
and downbearing. Zhi Ke is added to simultaneously regulate and rectify the
spleen and stomach's qi mechanism. Pei Lan opens depression and arouses
the spleen, while Fu Ling disinhibits dampness and fortifies the spleen.
This strengthens the spleen and stomach qi in order to dispel evils. When
all these medicinals are used together, their effect is to upbear the spleen
and downbear the stomach and free the flow of the qi mechanism. In addition,
pharmacological research has shown that Hou Po and Huang Lian are both anti-inflammatory
and kill Campylobacter pylori. Fu Ling increases the strength of the body's
immunity, and Pu Gong Yi disinhibits the bile, protects the liver, and combats
ulcers.
Conclusion
As readers hopefully will have seen, the above research suggests that Chinese
herbal medicine can be a safe and effective alternative for the treatment
of GERD. The three randomized, controlled trials (RCTs) are only a fraction
of those published in the last decade in China on the Chinese medical treatment
of GERD, and all of these RCTs have shown essentially the same thing: Chinese
medicine can treat this common disorder extremely well without any adverse
reactions or side effects.
Copyright Blue Poppy Press, 2006.
All rights reserved.
|