KEYWORDS: Botanical medicine, Herbals, Traditional use, Prescribing and formulation, Individualized, Naturopathy, Digestion/herbals, Dysbiosis
Current Trends in Naturopathic Prescribing for Digestive Disorders
Jillian Stansbury, ND
Developments within the Profession
As the naturopathic universities have matured and become increasingly recognized by state departments of health and education, and contracted with insurance panels, Medicare, and other entities, the profession has gained increasing structure and organization. With this continued development have come new responsibilities and possibly compromises in terms of the natural roots of the profession. Traditionally, naturopathic training placed great emphasis on the healing powers of nature, so physicians of the older ranks are watching with concern as the schools embrace pharmaceuticals as the new standard of care, in order to work with existing legal and medical structures. It is difficult to gain a deep, nuanced understanding of botanical medicine if it is not emphasized or modeled. Consequently, traditional herbal wisdom and skills may not continue to be passed down through the ranks of the profession. Although botanical medicine is certainly taught, I often see students who are still confused about how to use botanicals when that does not involve pulling a commercial product off the shelf.
I believe we are losing the knowledge of in-depth herbal prescribing and formulation for specific niche indications. Various diagnoses are treated somewhat superficially with commercial herbal formulas—what is referred to in some herbal circles as green allopathy. In clinical practice, it is important to know how to individualize or change a formula, not only for a specific diagnosis, but also for different presentations and constitutions.
Within the naturopathic profession today, there are handfuls of people like myself who customize individual herbal formulas; but at this point, the majority of practitioners do not. Rather, they use commercial products that are manufactured for a particular diagnosis such as ulcers, migraines, or sinus infections. Some of these formulations are quite good; the companies have demonstrated a great deal of finesse in evaluating the traditional literature and the research to develop these products. Physicians find these preparations attractive, since they are busy seeing patients, processing paperwork for the insurance companies, and staying afloat. However, this practice robs students and clinicians of in-depth experience and comfort with individualized formulating. I feel this is one of the key reasons I see so many students about to graduate who are still at a loss regarding how to put together an effective formula based on specific indications.
I see a vital need to keep alive herbal prescribing skills, familiarity with the materia medica, and the energetic and constitutional fine-tuning that has been the tradition in disciplines such as Chinese herbal medicine. We need to consider not just a diagnosis, but the person who has the diagnosis, the underlying factors driving illness or pathology, and the sum totality of the patient’s symptoms, in the context of the strengths and weaknesses of their various organ systems.
Formulating for Digestive Disorders
When confronted with complex clinical presentations, we have a wealth of traditional herbalism on which to draw. I cherish the work of the eclectic authors of the late 1800s and early 1900s and have learned a great deal from their detailed writings. Similarly, employing the wisdom of Chinese medicine, we can look to patterns of heat, cold, stagnation, dampness, and so on, search out herbs that are specifically indicated, and augment them with sophisticatedly chosen synergists and complementary botanicals. Applying this approach to prescribing for digestive disorders, familiar patient presentations are discussed in terms of developing specific herbal formulations, summarized here and in Table 1.
-
Hypochlorhydria.
Whether due to aging or other insufficiency, a patient with digestive issues who is losing weight, osteoporotic, or exhibiting poor wound healing may be hypochlorhydric, and not metabolizing or absorbing nutrients sufficiently. In these cases, the use of warming, stimulating, and acidifying herbs and supplements, such as lemon juice, gentian, or vinegar “aperitifs” taken before meals may promote HCl secretion and improve digestion. Bitter herbs such as Artemisia, also taken before meals, will improve hypochlorhydria. Hot or stimulating herbs are given to bring more blood to the gastrointestinal system and enhance the absorption of nutrients: ginger (Zingiber) or black pepper (Piper nigrum) can be used in capsule form taken with the meal, or as a condiment, spice, or dressing with the food. Some patients will benefit from an HCL supplement, initiated at the very lowest dosage and titrated up gradually, as well as pancreatic enzymes.
-
Biliary and Pancreatic Insufficiency.
Poor bile flow can result in gallstones and is also associated with intolerance of fatty foods, steatorrhea (excess fat in the stool), right upper quadrant pain, and in some cases, pain that radiates to the right shoulder, tip of the right scapula, or between the scapula. Liver stressors such as inflammation, environmental toxins, or excessive hormonal workloads (due to hormone-laden animal products or exposure to hormone disruptive chemicals) may contribute to biliary insufficiency. Lipotropic agents such as choline, betaine, and betalains are indicated, along with alterative and cholagogue herbs. Herbs such as berberine (extracted of Mahonia) and dandelion (Taraxacum) are gentle and all purpose, while celadine (Chelidonium) is a strong cholagogue, useful to increase bile flow but contraindicated for acute biliary spasms or gallbladder attacks.
-
Gastroparesis.
Impaired motility can be caused by hypochlorhydria, small intestinal bacterial overgrowth (SIBO), or long-standing constipation, contributing to the loss of gastric motility and intestinal peristalsis. Gastroparesis is suggested by loss of appetite, nausea, a full feeling after eating only small amounts, or even vomiting after meals. Agents that enhance motility include fiber, bitters such as Artemisia, gentian, or rhubarb (Rheum), and prolonged chewing (including chewing gum) which can stimulate peristalsis and motility reflexes. Improving liver function and treating any intestinal dysbiosis will help the intestines better receive stomach contents and support optimal motility.
-
Hyperreactivity of the Intestinal Mucosa
. Reactions such as allergic sensitivity in the digestive tract require herbs that reduce mast cell, platelet, and immune reactivity and are especially appropriate for patients with concomitant eczema, asthma, chemical sensitivity, or hay fever. Screen patents with IBS symptoms for hypersensitivity and immune reactions. Essential fatty acid and antioxidant supplements are indicated, as well as herbs that reduce allergic reactivity. Dong quai (Angelica sinensis), red sage (Salvia miltiorrhiza), skullcap (Scutellaria bacailensis), and turmeric (Curcuma longa) are herbs noted to reduce allergic, immune, and vascular hyper reactivity due a variety of molecular mechanisms.
-
Leaky Gut.
This pathology can result from any of the above dynamics, and in a chicken-and-egg cycle, can both cause systemic allergic reactivity and result from hyperreactivity. Indications of leaky gut include skin rashes, hives, vague joint and/or muscle pain, frequent headaches, or insidious general malaise associated with digestive issues. In these cases, work on restoring gut flora, as with dysbiosis and SIBO, and offer agents that improve cell-to-cell adherence and tight junction integrity of the intestinal mucosal cells, supporting barrier functions with agents such as Aloe vera gel that restore and nourish mucosal cells. Aloe gel and other mucilaginous agents such as slippery elm (Ulmus) may be added to smoothies. Apple pectin can help support cell barriers and integrity and can also be incorporated into smoothies or prepared in truffles. Other medical foods that address leaky gut include demulcent teas, bone broths, and seaweed preparations, as well as nutritional supplements such as collagen, hyaluronic acid, lecithin, and phosphatidylcholine.
-
Dysbiosis
. When patients with digestive complains present with a coated tongue, foul breath, sluggish affect and fatigue, or are frequently ill or toxic, their GI symptoms are probably related to dysbiosis. Dysbiosis can be due to various underlying factors that include poor diet, high sugar consumption, diabetes, antibiotic use, poor motility, or genetics. Beneficial intestinal flora is supported by creating an aerobic situation in the intestines through a quality diet, optimal stomach acid, adequate levels of bile, and pancreatic enzymes, as well as blood sugar balance, good intestinal circulation, improved motility, and healthy liver function. Antimicrobial herbs that can help deter the overgrowth of pathogenic bacteria may sometimes be required and include goldenseal (Hydrastis), garlic (Allium), or oil of oregano (Origanum vulgare) and in some cases, pharmaceutical antibiotics. Berberine capsules are readily available and have gentle antimicrobial effects, as well as many biliary and metabolic supportive benefits. When bloating and gas are severe, carminative herbs such as chamomile (Matricaria), mint (Mentha), ginger (Zingiber), and fennel (Foeniculum) are helpful, and frequently, they are fast acting. In all cases, the emphasis is on eliminating simple sugars and carbohydrates that promote pathogenic bacteria, increasing fiber that supports motility and aerobic flora, supplementing probiotics, and introducing liver supportive and alterative formulas.
-
SIBO
. Small intestinal bowel overgrowth is a particular type of dysbiosis in which flora normally found in the colon become established in the small bowel, causing dyspeptic symptoms, and chronic bloating and gas. SIBO does not respond well to the use of probiotics, as that may further exacerbate bacterial overgrowth. Rather, the use of antimicrobial herbs and general digestive support is indicated. SIBO occasionally requires a course of antibiotics but should be followed by motility-enhancing herbs and gentle antimicrobials, such as enteric-coated mint oil; berberine capsules; a tea of burdock root (Arctium), dandelion root (Taraxacum), or licorice (Glycyrrhiza); and cholagogues and/or alterative herbs specifically indicated to promote bile flow. Some patients will benefit from hydrochloric acid or pancreatic enzyme supplements to better digest food that is delivered to the small bowel.
Actions and Indications—Herbs Affecting Digestion
When considering the mechanisms of action needed to support digestion and intestinal flora, primary categories of herbs include acidifiers, antiallergy herbs, antimicrobials, astringents, carminatives, cholagogues/alteratives, demulcents, and motility support/laxatives. To treat an acute flare up of IBS in an atopic individual, for example, we might combine a demulcent with a carminative and an antiallergy herb. Once a handful of herbs with the desired action are selected, the clinician may further select the best, and most potentially effective herbs based on the energetic and constitutional niche indications or the pattern recognized to fit the sum totality of the patient’s case. The following are useful digestive support herbs, organized by their mechanisms of action, including brief details on their specific indications.
Acidifiers:
Patients with hypochlorhydria may benefit from drinking fresh lemon juice in water before meals, or squeezing fresh lemon or lime on foods at the time of serving, provided they are not intolerant of citrus. Vinegar can also be effective, particularly products contain the microbial mother culture (the intact bacterial culture used to produce the acetic acid). Digestive beverages can be made nutritious by adding and macerating hot and spicy herbs, nutritive herbs, or a combination of the two in vinegar. This produces a sipping vinegar which is then consumed by the spoonful, or prepared into beverages, to acidify the stomach before meals. In addition to HCl supplements, the following botanicals are also used to promote digestive secretions:
-
Mugwort (Artemisia vulgaris)
This bitter herb is specific for insufficient digestive secretions, and parasites. Best used in small doses of tincture since the pure volatile oil of mugwort is potentially toxic and not appropriate for internal consumption.
-
Yellow Dock (Rumex crispus)
Rumex is specific for hypochlorhydria, malabsorption, and constipation, as well as skin eruptions secondary to digestive insufficiency, biliary insufficiency, or poor elimination with toxicity in the glands, tissues, or skin.
Antiallergy Herbs and Vascular Tonics:
Herbs that are traditionally used to treat allergies work in part via effects on platelets and their release of histamine and inflammatory mediators. Such actions may be referred to as platelet anti-aggregators or PAF-Inhibitors (Platelet Activating Factor-Inhibitor). Herbs that reduce histamine and allergic inflammation also commonly improve circulation, reduce excessive clotting, and reduce inflammation within the blood vessels themselves, referred to as blood movers in Traditional Chinese Medicine. Many additional molecular mechanisms have been identified, suggesting that such herbs can reduce oxidative stress and hypersensitivity reactions in a variety of tissues, including in the intestinal tract. Chinese formulas to treat IBS, Crohn’s disease, and other inflammatory and hypersensitivity reactions often include antiallergy, blood-moving, vascular-stabilizing herbs to reduce the inflammatory cascade that underlies many inflammatory bowel diseases. Dong quai (Angelica sinensis), red sage (Salvia miltiorrhiza), and scute (Scutellaria bacailensis) are among herbs that can be included in formulas to improve inflammation or atopic reactivity that extends to the digestive system
.
Antimicrobials and Antihelminthics:
Antimicrobials are specific for traveler’s diarrhea, dysbiosis, yeast overgrowth, parasites, and intestinal worms. These botanicals are also indicated for gastric ulcers and GERD, since occult Helicobacter infections may be a factor contributing to that pathology. Interestingly, although pharmaceutical antibiotics can harm beneficial intestinal flora and increase susceptibility to Clostridium, yeast overgrowth, and other opportunistic infections, herbal antimicrobials are rarely associated with such consequences or side effects. Effective antimicrobials include the following botanicals, as well as goldenseal (Hydrastis canadensis) and sweet Annie (Artemisia annua).
-
Black Walnut (Juglans nigra)
Juglans is one of the most widely used folkloric herbs for intestinal parasites, indicated for both diarrhea and constipation, acidic burping, bowel movements with a foul odor, and stinging, burning sensations. Juglans is also indicated for chronic acne and skin eruptions associated with digestive upset.
-
Garlic (Allium sativum)
Garlic is specific for individuals with poor circulation and insufficient secretions, poor digestion in the elderly, or for dryness of the mucous membranes. It has a warming and stimulating action; and as long as it is not consumed raw in excess, it effectively reduces intestinal inflammation and mucous in the stool due to parasites.
-
Oregano (Origanum vulgare)
Oregano may be used in teas, tinctures, and capsule form, especially when distension, gas, and full tender stomach and/or intestines accompany dysbiosis and/or parasitic infections.
-
Pau D’arco (Tabebuia impetiginosa)
This herb, also known as taheebo, has broad anti-microbial properties and can be taken as a tea or tincture for intestinal infections. The tannin content is specific for watery diarrhea due to infections and parasites.
-
Wormwood (Artemisia absinthinum)
Wormwood is used in small amounts for short durations, due to potential central nervous system toxicity. It is indicated for digestive upset, morning nausea, or vomiting associated with chronic irritation, including long-term alcoholism. Wormwood is also specific for pinworms, round worms, and parasites in general. The herb is warming and stimulating but potentially highly irritating, so low doses are used and/or combined with a carminative to minimize any harsh effects.
Astringents:
Astringents are indicated for exudative diarrhea, when endotoxins or hyperreactivity promote excessive mucous and watery secretions, or for bleeding as with bleeding ulcers or Crohn’s disease.
-
Agrimony (Agrimonia)
Specific for abdominal pain associated with digestive difficulty and tendency to diarrhea or mucous in the stool, agrimony is also indicated for renal colic with mucous and particulates in the urine.
-
Geranium (Geranium maculatum)
Geranium is indicated for profuse and chronic diarrhea leading to dehydration and exhaustion when there is mucous or blood in the stool.
-
Goldenseal (Hydrastis canadense)
This botanical is specific for infections characterized by altered flora and the development of biofilms, as well as chronic, thick, yellow purulence in mucous membranes of the eyes, mouth, throat, GI, or vaginal tissue.
-
White Oak Bark or Galls (Quercus alba)
Quercus is an excellent digestive astringent specific for swollen, atonic digestive passages with excessive mucous discharges, portal/liver congestion, and fluid stasis secondary to liver disease and/or alcoholism.
-
Witch Hazel (Hamamelis virginiana)
Indicated when there is the sensation of weight and fullness accompanying intestinal irritation and a tendency to watery diarrhea, witch hazel is especially relevant when there is poor venous return, fluid stasis, swollen tissues, or hemorrhoids.
Carminatives:
Carminatives dispel bloating and gas, often quite quickly, providing relief of discomfort and pain. Due to their anti-inflammatory and antiallergy actions, these botanicals are more than simply palliative when continued over time. The seeds of Apiacea family spices such as fennel (Foeniculum), cumin (Carum), and anise (Pimpinellum anisum) are all palatable and useful to include in teas and tinctures or in the form of powders used in smoothies.
-
Catnip (Nepeta cataria)
Nepeta is a carminative tonic for children’s digestive upset and flatulence, and for cranky babies who cry while doubling over or drawing their legs up in pain.
-
Chamomile (Matricaria recutita, chamomilla)
Chamomile tea is helpful for digestive symptoms that include burping, nausea, stomach pain, bloating, or gas and beneficial for cranky babies and toddlers with green watery stools. Matricaria is also specific for emotional stress or anxiety in adults when nervous stress exacerbates digestive upset, associated with sensitivity both emotionally and to pain.
-
Fennel (Foeniculum vulgare)
Tea made with fennel seeds can improve bloating, gas, distensive pain, and cramping for individuals with inflammation, IBS, intestinal infection, or ulcerative colitis, and is gentle for colic in babies.
-
Ginger (Zingiber officinale).
This warming, stimulating carminative is indicated in cases of dyspepsia and flatulent colic, irritant-induced gastritis, and for diarrhea due to atony of the intestinal tract, as it increases saliva and digestive secretions. Ginger is also specific for nausea and vomiting (whether due to motion sickness, infection, or atony) and a sour stomach with flatulence associated with the passage of undigested food.
-
Peppermint (Mentha piperita)
Mentha excels in treating queasy stomachs, nausea, bloating, burping, rumbling, painful gas, or flatulence, and colic in infants. Mentha is effective in tinctures, teas, topically as an essential oil, and as enteric-coated peppermint capsules that dissolve in the small bowel. In addition to rapid symptomatic relief, mint can shift the overgrowth of intestinal flora in the small bowel and help reduce chronic dyspepsia.
-
Prickly Ash (Xanthoxylum americanum)
Xanthoxylum bark stimulates digestive circulation and secretions in cases of digestive debility and insufficiency, and is specific for those with cold constitutions, weakness, lethargy, poor circulation, and low appetite.
Cholagogues, Alteratives, and Bitters:
Bitter herbs stimulate bile flow, an action referred to as a cholagogue or alterative. Most so-called alteratives are gentle, supporting fat metabolism and triggering peristalsis in the small intestine, while a few herbs are fairly powerful cholagogues, contraindicated for acute biliary spasm or blocked bile ducts. Alterative herbs enhance digestive, biliary, and liver function, nutrient assimilation, detoxification, and elimination of wastes, thereby improving numerous systemic issues, including coated tongue, bad breath, skin blemishes, and hormonal imbalances or susceptibility to infections. The stronger cholagogues are indicated when bile flow and digestive secretions are grossly insufficient, while the more gentle alteratives are used to safely nudge biliary congestion and peristalsis. Both strong cholagogues and gentle alteratives can be considered bitters, used for centuries to treat malabsorption, pancreatic insufficiency, simple constipation, and dysbiosis. However, all such remedies can potentially aggravate IBS, hypersensitivity, and/or intestinal reactivity, so it is best to begin with low doses and combine with demulcents and carminatives.
-
Artichoke (Cynara scolymus)
The leaves, stalks, and fruit of the artichoke serve as a gentle liver tonic, especially helpful to improve blood sugar, cholesterol, and hormonal imbalances.
-
Berberine/Oregon Grape (Mahonia aquifolium)
Also known as Berberis, Oregon grape is a gentle alterative and digestive tonic with many uses. One isolated constituent, berberine, is emerging as a versatile molecule to treat infection, dysbiosis, metabolic syndrome, diabetes, hyperlipidemia, and numerous other issues. Oregon Grape is specific for intestinal mucosal congestion with discharge, dysbiosis, and/or fungal infections, and associated coated swollen tongue, chronic catarrh, skin blemishes, or oral or gastric lesions (which older herbal texts refer to toxemia).
-
Black Radish ((Raphanus nigra)
Preparations of black radish have the unique ability to relax the musculature within the bile ducts and gallbladder in cases of biliary colic, and Raphanus is specific for impaired bile flow with dyspepsia and chronic constipation (used as fresh juice, tincture, or commercial capsules). Raphanus is especially useful for episodes of gallbladder colic, poor quality bile that is too thick to flow, or a gallbladder that appears full of grit or a sand-like substance, leading to frequent acute episodes of right upper quadrant pain.
-
Burdock (Arctium lappa)
This gentle alterative is indicated for dyspepsia, intestinal dysbiosis, and malabsorption, as well as acne and skin disorders and general malaise related to toxicity (also indicated for hyperestrogenism and hyperlipidemia).
-
Celadine (Chelidonium majus)
This powerful cholagogue and liver herb is specific for jaundice, biliary disease, gallstones, clay-colored stools that float, or hard dry stools, as well as pain or fullness in the right upper quadrant or right shoulder. While Chelidonium may allay nausea and pain related to biliary insufficiency, note that it is contraindicated during acute biliary colic and should be used with caution in those with hypersensitive gallbladder function.
-
Dandelion (Taraxacum officinalis)
Dandelion root is specific for coated tongue, gastric headaches, chronic constipation, and biliary insufficiency. Indicated for liver disorders, it is utilized for jaundice, pain in the right upper quadrant of the abdomen, liver congestion, and night sweats due to liver disease. The tea is gently laxative, yet often well tolerated in IBS, though it should be initiated with caution in such patients.
Demulcents:
Mucopolysaccharides in plants have a mucilaginous quality and an affinity fo
r
mucosa membranes. Consequently, they are effective for soothing pain and provide molecular building blocks for epithelial cells to regenerate glycosaminoglycan basement membranes, improving structural integrity in cases of mucosal irritation, leaky gut, and ulcers. The dry herbs are soaked for hours to best extract the mucilaginous compounds in the demulcent (ideally overnight in cold water) and consumed in tea form throughout the day for conditions such as ulcers, IBS irritation, or mucosal erosions. Demulcents can also be added to medicinal smoothies. Suppositories and enemas of demulcent herbs have been used historically to treat irritations, colonic lesions, and rectal fissures.
-
Slippery Elm (Ulmus fulva)
Slippery elm powders are prepared into porridge to be held in the stomach and to treat gastritis and gastric ulcers, while teas tend to reach the colon more effectively. Gentle and nourishing, this botanical quickly soothes acute pain and the diarrhea that results from irritating food, food allergy reactivity, or exposure to toxins (due to food chemicals, irritants, or pathogens). Marshmallow (Althea officinalis) powders and teas are used in an identical manner, but may have slightly more affinity for the urinary mucosa.
-
Licorice (Glycyrrhiza glabra)
Licorice has a myriad of medicinal uses, but is specifically indicated for allergies, hypersensitivity intestinal reactions, intestinal ulcers, or hard dry stools. Licorice is specific for exhaustive states and digestive disorders associated with chronic stress and overwork.
Motility Support and Laxatives:
When ingested food stagnates, it can ferment and result in eructations, bloating, and flatulence. Poor motility can also lead to shifts in bacterial populations, contributing to SIBO and dysbiosis.
-
Cascara (Rhamnus purshiana)
Cascara is a powerful irritant laxative most often used for loss of peristalsis, constipation, and atrophy of intestinal muscles. A carminative agent is required in formulas using Rhamnus to prevent the plant from causing intestinal cramping and explosive bowel movements. Cascara is contraindicated for intestinal irritation and IBS patients, even if they are constipated. Senna (Cassia senna) is used in an identical manner to cascara.
-
Gentian (Gentiana lutea)
Consumed in small quantities due to its strong stimulating effects on secretions and peristalsis, this bitter is specific for atony of the bowels with gastroparesis and/or chronic constipation. Gentian may improve circulatory and digestive insufficiency, including hypochlorhydria and anorexia, in those with cold constitutions and chronic stasis.
-
Turkey Rhubarb (Rheum palmatum, officinale)
Rheum species are specific for dysbiosis and motility disorders, when frequent nausea interferes with the appetite, and for those who feel quickly full after only a few bites, or experience gastric upset after meals with sour burning, a sense of fermentation, epigastric pain, and fullness. Rheum is also specific for diarrhea secondary to poor digestion higher in the GI tract. Small doses are most appropriate. Rheum should be avoided in cases of IBS or acute infectious diarrhea and is best combined with carminative agents to prevent any possible griping tendency.
The Daily Regimen
Many of my patients already consume a great many medications and supplements, so I do not want to add to the big handful of pills these people are consuming on a daily basis. In fact, I try to taper that down wherever possible and typically avoid giving people more than five pills at a meal. For any given patient, I might use a variety of different formulas. This approach could involve, for example, one tea, one botanical in capsule form, and one tincture, or perhaps a probiotic, as summarized in Table 2.
[
Please insert Table 2 about here or anywhere in this section, The Daily Regimen.]
The most effective strategy for dysbiosis involves slowly shifting the balance of intestinal flora from anaerobic to aerobic; but there is more to it than that, and the process could take as long as a year. Like raindrops in a stagnant pool, adding a few probiotics may just be a drop in the bucket or might even be harmful. However, if we are able to improve motility in the GI tract, that could begin to support more aerobic and beneficial strains of bacteria. I often use the analogy of creating a new garden. We cannot have exceptional garden soil simply by turning over backyard dirt. It may take a year of consistent effort, periodically adding a little sand, compost, and peat moss to establish good drainage and an environment that can support the beneficial microbes essential to a flourishing garden. Similarly, a healthy mix of flora in the intestinal ecosystem requires an aerobic situation, supported with quality food, ample fiber, and optimal production of stomach acid, bile, and pancreatic enzymes. Chewing appears important as well, as the act of chewing apparently stimulates motility; so patients with motility issues may benefit from prolonged mastication, for example chewing gum after all meals.
Fiber.
Do not underestimate the value of adding a fiber supplement. High fiber diets promote peristalsis and an aerobic ecosystem in the intestines; however, patients with IBS or motility disorders, such as gastroparesis, often are unable to tolerate a sudden increase in fiber intake. Slow, gradual dietary changes are most ideal. When GERD or hyperacidity symptoms are present, acid-blocking drugs are to be avoided as these contribute to SIBO and impair motility. In addition to optimizing the diet, work on supporting mucosal barrier functions. Initially, emphasize demulcent foods such as apple pectin or grated apples, oatmeal with slippery elm (Ulmus), and thin soups prepared from split peas, squash or pureed green beans as tolerated. The introduction of fiber supplements and high fiber diets usually involves a fair amount of trial and error, starting slowly, and gradually increasing the grams of fiber per meal or per day. Very small amounts of apple pectin seem better tolerated than psyllium seed products, in my experience. Although a normal dose might be a tablespoon or two, for someone with IBS a quarter teaspoon is a good initial dosage. If psychological issues are a factor, stress relief becomes important as well.
Apple Pectin Truffles.
Apple pectin truffles can be prepared from cashew butter, carob syrup, apple pectin, and culinary spices of choice, such as cinnamon, cocoa powder, or coconut flakes. Blend the nut butter and sweetener in a small bowl and add the apple pectin and desired spices to achieve a consistency like cookie dough. Form into balls ½ to 1 inch in diameter: two to four truffles can be consumed per day, either between meals or with meals. The truffles can be rolled in sesame or chia seeds for more protein, blended with slippery elm powder (Ulmus) for greater demulcent effect, or enhanced with reishi or astragalus powder for immune modulation. These truffles support good bacteria without being too high in carbohydrates and can be pleasantly filling and nourishing.
Digestive Beverages.
Digestive tonic beverages are prepared by topping a tablespoon of sipping vinegar with a cup or two of sparkling mineral water, or demulcent or carminative herbal tea. For those struggling to quit sweets and sodas, drinks can also be created by combining the vinegar with a ½ cup of actual fruit juice, and diluting with tea, ice water, or fresh squeezed lemon juice
Sipping Vinegars or Shrubs
. To make a vinegar shrub, fruit is placed in the blender, covered with apple cider vinegar, puréed, and then transferred to a jar. This mixture is shaken each day, and after 20 to 30 days, the mixture is pressed through a sieve, saving just the vinegar. These vinegars can be made with raspberries, blueberries, or purple grapes, as well as ripe, pitted peaches, mangoes, plums, or papaya.
Fire Cider.
Another classic digestive tonic recipe is fire cider, prepared by coarsely chopping 1 to 2 cups each of herbs such as ginger, habanero peppers, turmeric, garlic, onions, and/or horseradish, placing the herbs in a high-speed blender, covering the mixture with vinegar, and pureeing again. Transfer to a large canning jar and shake daily for a month. Strain and place the remaining vinegar in a clean storage jar. These vinegars can be held at room temperature; there is no need to refrigerate. Use the finished fire cider to prepare drinks, salad dressing, and marinades.
Nutritive Vinegars
. These supportive foods can be prepared by macerating nutritive high mineral herbs such as alfalfa (Medicago), oats (Avena), horsetail (Equisetum), nettles (Urtica), or gotu kola (Centella), in vinegar as described above. Turmeric, black pepper, and/or ginger also make a useful digestive vinegar. The possibilities are endless. Use the culinary vinegars in drinks, cooking, and medicinals.
Teas, Tinctures, and Supplements.
I love herbal teas for digestive support since they achieve direct surface contact with the digestive mucosa. Mint in tea form, for example, although weaker than the tincture form, seems to be more effective. Herbal tinctures do have their place, however, as cholagogues and alteratives. Creating herbal teas and tinctures is very person specific, and capsules may be used to complement the regimen, providing general support. For example, enteric-coated mint or various types of enteric-coated slippery elm capsules help a broad range of conditions that present as digestive pain or bloating and gas. Slippery elm in this form, or as a medicinal drink or porridge, is especially indicated where there is diarrhea, a great deal of mucous in the stool, or bleeding ulcers. Pancreatic enzymes, with or without HCl, may also be complementary to specifically indicated herbs.
Nut Milks and Medicinal Smoothies.
Rather than fruit and vegetable juices, which tend to be very high in sugars, I find some of the nut milks quite nourishing. It is important to note whether nuts cause a reaction—even almonds can cause sensitivity. However, coconut milk, hemp milk, and for some, oat milk can serve as the base for a smoothie. If fruit is tolerated, that may be added to the mix, especially berries due to their numerous anti-inflammatory and antioxidant effects. Berry flavonoids also protect collagen, helping to restore the gut lining in cases of leaky gut. Hibisicus teas offer valuable flavonoids as well and can be used as an ingredient in medicinal teas, sipping vinegars and smoothies. Botanicals can be added to nut milk beverages and smoothies (i.e. aloe gel, apple pectin, Astragalus powder, or seaweed alginates). Alginates are especially useful as alternatives to harmful antacids and useful in the treatment of GERD. Similarly, I sometimes use seaweeds in bone broth to offer demulcent and tissue-restorative sulfated polysaccharides to support mucous membrane integrity and regeneration.
Dietary Strategies.
Rather than undergoing expensive food allergy testing, I simply coach my patients to avoid common food allergens for two months and then reintroduce them one by one. The most frequent offenders are typically dairy, wheat, soy, corn, nuts, citrus, alcohol, caffeine, sugar, and foods in the nightshade family such as potatoes, tomatoes, and eggplant.
I usually just begin by having people avoid gluten-based products such as bread, crackers, pizza crust, and pasta. The diet can always be made more restrictive, eliminating peas, carrots, corn, and other carbohydrates, if needed, based on the initial results. A diet for SIBO may be even more stringent, keeping fiber levels high and eliminating any simple carbs.
At its most extreme, a low-carbohydrate diet may eliminate all fruits and even most vegetables temporarily, restricting the diet to just meat and bone broth for a few days while offering recovery herbs and medicines for someone with SIBO or other stubborn dysbiotic symptoms. For a patient who is acutely ill, such a diet makes sense for a short period of time, perhaps for a few weeks while we build them up with herbs. However, I like to add in important foods that are high in flavonoids, such as beets, broccoli, kale, and collards as soon as possible, and widen the diversity of vegetables from there.
Zucchini and squash, for example, are considered to be low FODMAP vegetables because they consist primarily of insoluble fiber, rather than quickly digestible fiber. By simmering these vegetables with meat or bones to yield soups and broth, one gets essential nutrients and minerals. Other simplified diet options include a small salad of baby greens, or sprouts, or finely chopped cabbage—foods that tend to be lower in easily fermentable fibers. This may be served with steamed greens, kale, or broccoli—whatever patients find most digestible. Those who can tolerate more carbohydrate and fiber might then add sweet potatoes, pumpkin, or green beans to soups and vegetable dishes, as tolerated.
I will individualize a patient’s diet to foods I suspect would be both optimal and realistic and customize a program of herbal teas and supplements, offering gut-restorative protocols, and restricting suspected trigger foods as much as possible. Two weeks is a reasonable length of time to assess initial results. If the patient is still unable to digest, if they have discomfort, diarrhea, or migraines, for example, we may need to simplify their diet even further for another week or two.
Fermented Foods
. Once general motility is restored with diet changes, fiber, and specifically indicated herbal therapies, fermented foods may be introduced. Some patients, such as those with SIBO, are unable to tolerate commercial probiotic supplements. However, most people are able to digest small servings of quality yogurt, sauerkraut, apple cider vinegar, kefir water, kombucha™, or fermented beet beverages. As with fiber supplements, begin with small quantities, and build up over weeks or even months. Once full servings of these fermented foods are tolerated, probiotics may be attempted. Choose a powdered product and put 1/8 of a teaspoon or less in drinking water to trickle through the sensitive GI tract over the course of the day. Once this is easily tolerated, increase the dosage gradually.
The Relevance of Botanical Medicine
There is a rich lineage of herbal knowledge earned through countless lifetimes, generations, and millennia, reflecting the empirical observation of entire cultures. In my opinion, such information is not-inferior or less trustworthy than published scientific studies. In fact, I have found the historical body of observation from herbalists such as the eclectics, for example, to have genuine clinical utility. Time-honored botanicals, recognized for their low toxicity, can be used clinically for specific symptoms, presentations, and constitutions, drawing from a vast wealth of empirical observation.
For the same reasons, I have dedicated the last 12 years to the study of ethnobotany of the Amazon, before that wisdom is lost. The situation in the naturopathic profession may not be as dire as the loss of indigenous cultures and their knowledge. However, I have noted the current trend pulling toward more allopathic systems and therapies, risking loss of the depth and breadth of the herbal wisdom that was once one of the foundations of the profession.
JILLIAN STANSBURY, ND
Dr. Stansbury is a primary care physician licensed in the state of Washington who specializes in herbal and natural medicine. She is the former Chair of the Botanical Medicine Department at National College of Naturopathic Medicine in Portland, Oregon, where she is currently a professor. In conjunction with her in-depth work in ethnobotany and herbal medicine, she provides workshops and lectures internationally on natural products chemistry and the clinical applications of botanicals. Dr. Stansbury leads biannual ethnobotany field courses throughout the world.
RESOURCES
Naturopathic Clinic and Consultations.
Battle Ground Healing Arts is a full-service medical clinic providing naturopathic and herbal medicine as well as primary care and consultations for individuals with chronic health issues. Located 30 minutes from Portland and Vancouver and 3 hours from Seattle, Dr. Stansbury welcomes new patients and frequently collaborates with other physicians on patient care.
Battle Ground Healing Arts
408 East Main Street
Battle Ground, WA
Phone: 360.687.4492
Website: BattleGroundHealingArts.com
Apothecary.
The Healing Arts Apothecary is open to the public and can fill herbal and medicinal prescriptions from other prescribers. Hundreds of dry herbs, tinctures, formulas, proprietary tea blends, and top-of-the-line supplements are available locally and by mail.
Phone: 360.687.4492
Training in Herbal Medicine and Ethnobotany.
In addition to professional training and conference presentations, Dr. Stansbury leads Ethnobotany Field Courses each July and New Year’s Holiday. Further information is available online.
Web link: BattleGroundHealingArts.com/events-classes/
Nancy Faass, MSW, MPH
Ms. Faass is a writer and editor in San Francisco who has worked on more than 50 books for major publishers. Director of the Health Writers’ Group for the past 20 years, she works collaboratively with clients to develop books, articles, Web content, white papers, manuals, and blogs, and can be reached by emailing info@HealthWritersGroup.com or calling (415) 922-6234.
Table 1. Formulating for Niche Indications
Presentation |
Intervention |
Specific Applications |
|---|---|---|
HYPOCHLORHYDRIAAssociated with GI infection or aging Digestive issues with weight loss Malnutrition due to poor absorption Osteoporosis or poor wound healing Various dyspeptic symptoms, gas, bloating Poor digestion of large meals, fats, meat |
Acidifiers | Lemon juice; vinegar shrubs, fire cider, and nutritive vinegars; botanicals such as yellow dock |
| Strong bitters | Artemisia, gentian, rhubarb | |
| Digestants | HCl and pancreatic enzymes; ginger, black pepper | |
| Cholagogues | Artichoke, burdock, celadine, dandelion root, goldenseal, milk thistle, turmeric | |
| Lipotropic agents | Betaine, betalains, choline; artichoke, milk thistle | |
BILIARY/PANCREATIC INSUFFICIENCYIntolerance of fatty foods Bloating and gas; steatorrhea Gallstones; right upper-quadrant pain |
Cholagogues |
Black radish, dandelion root, Oregon grape Celadine, but avoid with acute biliary colic |
| Bitters | Artemisia, gentian, rhubarb | |
GASTROPARESISVarious dyspeptic symptoms Feeling full after only a few bites Nausea and vomiting after meals Belching, pressure, and distensive pain |
Chewing | Chewing for 20-30 minutes at meals; non-sugar gum |
| Carminatives | Catnip, chamomile, ginger, mint, wild yam | |
| Fiber | Soluble, insoluble fiber, both dietary and supplemental | |
| Demulcents for diarrhea, mucous | Alginates from seaweed, aloe vera, comfrey, licorice, oatmeal, slippery elm | |
| Laxative | Rhubarb, senna | |
LEAKY GUT SYNDROMESystemic allergic or hyperreactivity, food sensitivity, skin rashes, hives, vague joint or muscle pain, headaches, malaise or fatigue, systemic diseases or infections |
Medical foods, demulcents, for barrier functions | Aloe gel in smoothies, collagen, hyaluronic acid, lecithin, pectin, phosphatidylcholine; bone broths, seaweed; demulcent herbs such as slippery elm |
| Digestants | HCl and pancreatic enzymes, bromelain, papain, possibly bitters |
Presentation |
Intervention |
Specific Applications |
|---|---|---|
HYPERREACTIVITY—INTESTINAL MUCOSAIntestinal reactivity with concomitant eczema, asthma, hay fever, or chemical sensitivity; bloating, flatulence, and/or intestinal cramps; chronic dyspepsia; emergent diarrhea with mucous or blood |
Nutritional supplements | Antioxidants; essential fatty acids; flavonoids, especially quercetin, resveratrol; probiotics |
| Antiallergy herbs | Butterbur, dong quai, ginger, licorice, red sage, skullcap, turmeric | |
| Astringents for diarrhea, mucous | Agrimony, geranium, goldenseal, white oak bark or galls, witch hazel | |
DYSBIOSISCoated tongue, foul breath, sluggishness or fatigue; frequent infections, illness, or toxicity, skin blemishes Poor digestion, frequent bloating, gas, diarrhea, and/or constipation, compromised GI function Linked to poor diet, sugar intake, diabetes, antibiotic use, poor motility, or genetics |
Motility support |
High-fiber diet and fiber supplements Cascara, rhubarb, senna |
| Carminatives | Catnip, chamomile, fennel, ginger, mint, prickly ash | |
| Cholagogues | Artichoke, berberine capsules, burdock, dandelion, Oregon grape, rhubarb | |
| Liver support | Artichoke, beets, milk thistle, turmeric | |
| Antimicrobials | Berberine, black walnut, chamomile, garlic, goldenseal, mugwort, oil of oregano, pau d’arco, whole Oregon grape root, wormwood | |
SMALL INTESTINE BACTERIAL OVERGROWTHDyspepsia, chronic bloating and gas Probiotics simply worsen |
Digestants | HCl and pancreatic enzymes, bitters, bromelain, papain |
| Carminatives | Anise, caraway seeds, chamomile, fennel, mint | |
| Cholagogues and alteratives | Artichoke, berberine capsules, burdock, dandelion, Oregon grape, rhubarb | |
| Antimicrobials | Berberine capsules, burdock root, dandelion root tea, enteric-coated mint oil, licorice |
Table 2. Clinical Resources
Diet |
Raw and cooked fresh vegetables, quality meats in moderation. Avoid grains, simple carbs, or sugars |
|---|---|
Fiber |
Non-irritating fiber supplement: apple pectin, psyllium powder, fresh vegetables; 20–40 gr/daily |
Teas |
3 or 4 cups/day. For acute infections, pain, cramping, 6–8 cups/day, reduce with improvement |
Tinctures |
1/2 to 1 teaspoon, 3 to 6 times daily in a customized regimen |
Tonic Beverages |
Fruit-based sipping vinegar, fire cider (containing hot herbs), nutritive vinegars |
Nut Milks andMedicinal Smoothies |
Nutritious milk bases made with nuts, seeds, or oats, with added aloe gel, apple pectin, astragalus, reishi, or seaweed |
Supplements |
HCl , digestive enzymes, probiotics, lipotropics (for bile flow, detoxification) |
Botanicals |
Alginates (for GERD), antimicrobials (for SIBO), enteric-coated mint (for cramping) |









0 Comments