Optimizing Metabolism
by Ingrid Kohlstadt, MD, MPH, FACN, FACPM
Emerging Science ‘Irons Out’ a Treatment Plan for Anemia
The latest research shows that less of anemia can be explained by iron deficiency than previously thought, and even when anemia is caused by iron deficiency, iron pills are not the best treatment.
Research is revealing that anemia is sometimes part of a bigger strategy. According to a review in the November 9, 2012, edition of Science, the Iron Age is now and its battles lie within us. “Iron lies at the center of a battle for nutritional resource[s] between higher organisms and their microbial pathogens.”
The biochemistry underlying anemia is, in some ways, analogous to chess. The game of knights is popular in my home as my 6-year-old is learning the strategies while her 3-year-old brother acts out iron-clad battles atop a hobbyhorse, wielding a paper sword and armored in his gray fleece pullover.
My daughter prefers playing chess with Dad, claiming that I keep her in check too long. Similarly, although the human body puts most pathogens in checkmate long before they significantly compromise health, some viruses such as HIV-1, parasites such as malaria, and bacteria such as tuberculosis employ advanced strategies, and the human host’s best-case scenario is prolonged check.
A key defense strategy that the human body uses is to withhold iron from invading pathogens. Think of iron like the chess king. Very little iron is free or unbound. Several proteins are assigned key roles for protecting iron. These “pawns” include transferrin, lactoferrin, ferritin, haptoglobin (hemoglobin chaperone), and hemopexin (heme chaperone), all of which are modified in the presence of infection. The recently discovered hormone hepcidin might be compared to a chess queen, because it is the key regulator of iron metabolism. Hepcidin responds to both nutrient status and infection. When an infection is present, hepcidin production is revved and iron is even more tightly garrisoned sometimes leading to mild anemia.
Taking an iron supplement can overwhelm hepcidin’s ability to garrison iron and places iron weaponry in enemy (pathogen) hands. In retrospect this appears to be what occurred in a large iron supplement trial among iron-deficient children from the Pemba Islands off the coast of Africa. The trial was stopped early because the children who got supplemental iron fared worse. A study of iron-deficient Somali refugees recorded five times the number of infections in the treated group compared with the control group. Among the infections were reactivated malaria, brucellosis, and tuberculosis – preexisting infections that were no longer in check.
Iron supplementation turns the chess table in other unfavorable ways. Iron pills can lead to deficiency of other minerals, especially chromium, which usually accompanies iron in food sources. Excess iron can be inflammatory, rusting (oxidizing) during noninfectious metabolic stress. Iron appears to interfere with the balance of intestinal bacteria among its well-established gastrointestinal symptoms.
Hepcidin and the iron-infection axis are a recently elucidated antimicrobial strategy. However, in light of the intricate balance described above, it appears noteworthy that in the absence of a genetic condition called primary hemochromatosis, the human body absorbs a mere 5% to 15% of ingested iron, even following acute blood (iron) loss. Therefore rather than asking how much iron does a patient need, the more salient question is likely to be, how can a patient make the body a safer place for iron?
If not with iron, how might one treat iron deficiency anemia? I’ve got the “check” list for you!
-
Eat green leafy vegetables, including herbs. These contain several nutrients needed for building red blood cells, including nonheme iron, which is easier for the body to regulate than heme iron. Some scientists would say that, more importantly than a source of iron, greens are alkalinizing: They help the body maintain an optimal pH, as elaborated in step 2.
-
Drink lime juice. Vitamin C supports iron absorption, and lime juice contains citrate with relatively little fruit sugar. Lime juice is acidic. This is its physical chemistry as measured with litmus paper. However, because citrus enters the citric acid (Krebs) cycle, producing bicarbonate, its biochemistry is alkalinizing. Alkalinizing additions to the diet help offset the acidifying effects of starch, sugar, and salt, all too common in Western diets. The micronutrient chessboard favors the human host with optimal blood pH, because many enzymes including those for oxygen transport incorporate iron, and their solubility is highly pH dependent.
-
Only after steps 1 and 2, eat heme iron in the form of gently cooked lean meats. Iron is an element with several valency states or charges. That means that how food is processed and prepared can change the physical properties of iron present in it. Research to demonstrate the safety of certain cooking practices has not been done. Until safety is shown, choose lean meats that have not been irradiated and do not microwave them. Salting and charbroiling meats are harmful for related reasons and should be avoided.
-
Use iron cookware. Cooking with an iron skillet infuses a small amount of iron every day, especially with acidic and fermented foods. Favorable results have been published on treating anemia of pregnancy by preparing food with iron skillets, and the results appear to be generalizable to most forms of anemia.
-
Enlist the help of “friendly” microbes. Based on the complex metabolic pathways outlined above, resisting the infections in the iron-infection axis indirectly treats anemia. I’ve been impressed with the published literature on the effectiveness of strategic probiotic use in reducing inflammation and infection risk. I recommend a specific chewable probiotic containing Lactobacilli. Yogurt – cultured milk and live active cultures, and not a bunch of other ingredients – may be useful for those appropriately aiming to use food before supplements.
Here’s wishing you a favorable check-up and a nutritiously delicious spring season!
Summary
Predicting who will receive a net benefit from iron supplementation does not seem possible. It depends on genetic background, preexisting iron status, and both past and future infectious exposures. Even when anemia responds to iron supplementation the collateral damage from the supplements is often high and includes elevated risk of infections. Anemia can respond to a biochemical environment that favors iron absorption and utilization. Steps are outlined here.
Ingrid Kohlstadt, MD, MPH, FACN, FACPM, is the founder of INGRIDients Inc., where she has edited Advancing Medicine with Food and Nutrients, 2nd edition (CRC Press; December 2012). On the faculty of Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Dr. Kohlstadt is researching an approach to leverage nutrition more fully in disease prevention.









0 Comments