Optimizing Metabolism
by Ingrid Kohlstadt, MD, MPH, FACPM, FACN
The Proof and the Pudding:
Using What We Know About the Human Microbiome
April welcomes Earth Day, when scintillating research findings inspire us to save the Earth one ecosystem at a time. This column takes a broad approach to saving our most intimate ecosystem – the microbiome.
All fields of science are turning up evidence that the human microbiome sways human health in complex and profound ways. For example, this edition of Townsend Letter covers the health topics of seasonal allergy disorders, skin disease, and eye health, and published research supports the assertion that all of these medical conditions are entwined with the health of the microbiome.
Microbiome research is causing us to rethink long-held scientific assumptions about the origins of disease. Even so, most published papers draw that well-known conclusion, “More research is needed.” I want to start seeing an equally valid conclusion. “More implications for medical and public health practice are needed.” The evidence about the microbiome is so compelling that we need to use it.
If you know the expression “The proof is in the pudding,” you catch my sentiment. The expression dates back to Medieval England. I imagine that it started when an argument arose among the royal court when they were boasting about the upcoming holiday festivities. Tired of the banter, one noble lord insisted: “Enough talk about the holiday plum pudding, my lady. When I can taste it, I’ll believe how good it is.” Then the court jester stepped in to smooth tensions, “Ah, indeed. The proof is in the pudding.”
So how do we get to “pudding” prevention into practice?
What Does Proof Look Like for Biologic Systems?
For one, you can’t hammer a chiffon pie into the wall. We shouldn’t delay a decision for a patient or public health, in order to await hard-and-fast evidence. Rather we should use the best evidence we’ve got at the time, even if it wiggles like gelled pudding.
Our present medical model tends to compare all clinical evidence to randomized double-blind, placebo-controlled trials. That may be appropriate for clinical drug research, however living ecosystem are not studied the same way as a chemical compound. It’s not that the epidemiologic output from microbiome research is stronger or weaker, just that it’s different. What’s important from a prevention perspective is how accurately the data correlate with patient symptoms. From that vantage point the research findings on the microbiome are compelling.
Why Would Something Taste Good If It’s Bad for You?
Like pudding, prevention is a matter of taste. And asking patients about their taste perceptions often provides clinically useful clues about their metabolism. For example, rather than telling patients to eat less sugar, health-care providers facilitate their patients’ health more effectively by exploring with them the cause of unrelenting carbohydrate cravings. Often a microbiome out of balance is a sort of medical smoking gun.
How Do We Improve Uptake of Foods That Nourish the Microbiome?
You can make holiday plum pudding with prunes, but don’t ever call them that. To illustrate my assertion, let me share some intriguing statistics from a youth nutrition program that I developed. Only a few children who liked raisins ever tried dried grapes, and prunes usually get half as many “likes” as dried plums. From a public health perspective, we could do a lot more to market these foods. Some of them need a complete makeover.
Microbiome research is a neon highlighter. It makes the importance of the dietary “F”s – Fiber, Fermented foods, and Phytonutrients too visible to overlook. It’s also proven that there’s no such thing as a “smart cookie.” Sugar, fake sugars, and synthetic trans fats are food for microbial sluggards.
Based on the microbiome research, we shouldn’t assume that the live active cultures in cultured dairy products are indeed “pro”biotics; that is, beneficial to our health. Milk is the growth medium for the bacteria that digest the milk and turn it into yogurt. If the growth medium contains 0% fat, high-intensity sweeteners, added sugar, or all of the above, how do I know that the beneficial microbes will be the ones that grow?
The Microbiome’s Relevance to Food Safety
Plum pudding used to be more popular for holiday parties than it is now. For public health departments around the country, that’s a relief, because improperly prepared pudding frequently leads to foodborne illness.
I write this in fond memory of Dr. Leon Gordis (1934–2015), longtime chair of epidemiology at Johns Hopkins University. Imagine an 8 a.m. lecture that filled the hall by 7:50 because so many students wanted to watch 2 × 2 epidemiologic tables spring to life.
The 2 × 2 tables are a back-of-the-napkin way to tally who got sick at the holiday party of those who ate the plum pudding and who didn’t eat it. By going through each food, one can calculate the most likely causative one. What was interesting was that not everybody who got sick ate the pudding and not everyone who ate the pudding got sick, even though the pudding was the cause. When I directed a local health department, the outbreaks that I investigated followed this pattern too, because everyone’s microbiome differs. Outbreaks aren’t usually a question of whether the infectious agent is present, but in what concentrations relative to the microbiomes of the people exposed.
Insights into Why Eradication Seldom Works
Unless your name is President Jimmy Carter and the organism that you want to eradicate is Dracunculus medinensis (Guinea worm), you may want to reconsider eradication as a medical treatment strategy. Prescribing pharmaceutical commandos to assassinate pathogens usually results in reinfection and relapse of symptoms. Microbiome research is confirming that peaceful cohabitation may be as effective, and easier to achieve especially alongside nutritional strategies.
As a medical student in 1990 I traveled to Peru and sampled holiday pudding called mazamorra morada, which is purple – not from plums but from purple corn. Although the pudding was exceptional, my travel was for the “proof,” an introduction to the microbiome. I researched how H. pylori exposure during infancy might influence gastrointestinal physiology in adulthood.1 A leader in the H. pylori research, Dr. Marty Blazer, commended my student paper and encouraged me not to forget the conclusions during my clinical training. “Eradication of H. pylori isn’t the answer,” he emphasized. Now 25 years later, Marty is furthering his claim with compelling evidence that the way antibiotics change the microbiome actually contributes to obesity.
How Do You Regulate Probiotics and Other Microbiome Therapies?
Most of us aren’t on the edge of our seats about how the FDA is regulating probiotics. Yet it’s a practical application of the microbiome research. Probiotic capsules are regulated as dietary supplements. That seems straightforward even if diet isn’t the primary source of the microbiome. But if the capsules are added to boiled milk to culture yogurt, then they are regulated instead as a food ingredient. The ultimate in probiotics are treatments for C. difficile infection, and these therapies are regulated as biologics. But when it comes to public safety and probiotics, it’s the pharmaceutical regulators who are appropriately the most concerned. That’s because of the potential for probiotics to create antimicrobial resistance. Based on microbiome research, more attention is being given to reusable medical devices and how they are sterilized between patients.
Conclusion
Microbiome research is providing real-time applications for medical and public health practice. These include prioritizing what is important on food labels, personalizing medical treatments to include gut health, and responding to the findings with public health foresight. Another important conclusion is that a thank-you is in order – happy Earth Day to the health professionals and clinical researchers who are caring for the planet one ecosystem at a time!
Ingrid Kohlstadt, MD, MPH, FACPM, FACN
Faculty Associate, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health
Executive Director, NutriBee National Nutrition Competition Inc.
Editor, Advancing Medicine with Food and Nutrients (CRC Press; 2013)
Notes
-
Kohlstadt I, Antunez de Mayolo A, Gastrointestinal Physiology Working Group, Ramirez-Icaza C. Parietal cell antibodies among Peruvians with gastric pathology. Scand J Gastroenterol. 1993.









0 Comments